Call, Stop By, Ship, or Road Trip

Call!

920-868-2743 reservations and special orders

Reservations
A full size baked pie must be reserved by phone at least a day in advance. 920-868-2743
We are happy to accept advanced reservations for:
Cutie Pies (5in)
Crust cookies or crust crackers
Frozen pies
Slices are generally plentiful but may be reserved day-of.
Need to pick-up after hours or when we’re closed? Inquire about a “porch pick-up”.
Need your order brought out to your car or other accommodation? Just let us know and we’ll be happy make arrangements.

Special Orders
Creme Pies, No Sugar Added, Crumble Top, please try to allow 3 days notice.

Stop By! 9106 State Hwy 42 Fish Creek in The Settlement Shops
Available daily in a variety of flavors:
SLICES: available Ala Mode!
CUTIE PIES (5in)
PRECIOUS PIES (3in): get a flight!
FROZEN PIES: 30+ flavors, 2 sizes
CRUST COOKIES
CRUST CRACKERS
Need your order brought out to your car or other accommodation? Just let us know and we’ll be happy make arrangements.
We also feature Sweetie Pies merch, Door Co treasures, local art & more!

Shipping

Click Buy Online at the top of this page. All pies are shipped frozen raw. Baking instructions are included.

Road Trip!
Learn about our annual Road Trip Delivery. Click Buy Online or Road Trip at the top of this page. All pies are delivered frozen raw. Baking instructions are included.